Stand on the shore of the Conway chain of lakes on a Sunday in the late 1880s and you would have seen something that did not belong. Men in white flannels playing polo on horseback. A cricket match on a cleared field. Small sailboats working the water in the afternoon wind. Tea in the shade. And all around it, rows of orange trees running down to the lakes, because the oranges were what paid for the rest. This was Conway, a few miles south of a young Orlando, and for about a decade a cluster of English families tried to build a small piece of England here, on the fruit of Florida sand.
Lake country, south of the city
The lakes were the whole reason. Four of them, joined together, nearly eighteen hundred acres of open water: Big and Little Lake Conway, South Lake Conway, and Lake Gatlin. Before the English, before the oranges, that water had drawn the Army.
Where the town began
In 1838, during the Second Seminole War, the United States Army built a log post called Fort Gatlin on a spot chosen for its water. It sat between three small lakes, so attackers could be seen coming from almost any direction. The fort was abandoned in 1849, but a few soldiers and families stayed on to grow citrus and run cattle, and that small settlement grew into the seat of Orange County. The county was still called Mosquito County when it started.
The lakes kept their English name from this early period. In 1843 a surveyor named Benjamin Whitner mapped the land here and named the largest lake for his boss, Valentine Y. Conway, the Surveyor General of Florida. Conway himself probably never saw it. His name simply stuck to the water, and later to the whole settlement around it.
A little England on the water
By the 1880s the groves had become the thing Central Florida did best, and the money that oranges could make drew an unusual crowd. Families came out from England to plant citrus on the high sandy ground around the lakes. They brought their own idea of how a comfortable life should look, and set it down whole in the Florida pine.
So on the Conway lakes there were polo ponies and cricket bats and tennis, and sailing races on Sunday afternoons, and high tea. Polo clubs and afternoon tea became the fashion across the whole young city because of them. It was a gentlemen's colony, financed by the orange, played out on the edge of a frontier town that did not yet have paved streets.
They built themselves a proper clubhouse in town. In 1886 an Englishman named Gordon Rogers put up a two-story building at the corner of Pine and Magnolia in downtown Orlando, an ornate Queen Anne pile with a club for the city's English community on the upper floor, hosting its dances and its theater. It still stands. It is the oldest surviving building in downtown Orlando.
The whole arrangement rested on one assumption: that the oranges would keep coming. The groves had carried Central Florida for a generation. There was no reason to think the next winter would be any different from the last.
The two nights
The first cold came the night of December 29, 1894. A hard freeze dropped over Central Florida and killed the fruit on the trees, a bad loss but a survivable one. Then the weather turned mild again, the groves pushed out tender new growth, and the growers let themselves believe the worst was behind them.
It was not. On February 7, 1895, a second freeze came down, far colder than the first, and found the trees full of soft new shoots. This one did not just take the fruit. It killed the trees to the ground. Across the county that had been named for the orange, growers counted more than twenty-one thousand acres of citrus and, that season, not a single box of fruit.
Everything the colony had built sat on top of the orange crop. Two winter nights took the crop, and the colony with it.The part no one could plan for
For families whose entire reason to be in Florida was citrus, there was nothing to stay for. Replanting meant seven years of waiting for new trees to bear, with no income in between, and most of the small growers did not have the money to wait. The English packed up and left. Local memory still tells it as a kind of legend, that some of them fled so fast they left the dishes unwashed on the dining-room table.
The citrus belt pulled south after that, down to the warmer center of the peninsula, and it never fully came back to this ground. The polo ponies went quiet. The clubhouse in town lost its English dances. What the colonists left behind was the name on the lakes, the old green building at Pine and Magnolia, and a lesson the place would have to learn again.
What the lakes kept
Conway did not become a city of orange barons. It became lake country. Through the decades while the rest of Orlando filled in around it, the land between the lakes stayed low and green and shaded, big oaks over the water, the kind of old-Orlando pocket that never grew gates or towers. The thing that makes it beautiful is the same thing that first drew the Army and the English: the water, and the trees.
And the trees are exactly where the old lesson comes back. Because the modern version of a killing freeze is not frost. It is wind.
The modern switch
In the autumn of 2004, three hurricanes crossed Central Florida in the space of six weeks. Charley came over on August 13 and put a gust near a hundred and five miles an hour across Orlando. Frances followed on September 5, and Jeanne on September 26. Each time, the wind went to work on the one thing a shaded lakeside neighborhood cannot move out of the way: its own trees. The big oaks came down, and the falling trunks took the power lines with them.
Each of those storms left roughly two million Florida homes and businesses in the dark. In the Orlando area the power stayed off for days, and then it happened again, and then a third time, the same autumn. The oaks that shade a Conway street in July are the oaks lying across its wires in September.
And the dark does not lift when the wind stops. The storm is over in a night. The power comes back slowly, pole by pole, crew by crew, and nothing a homeowner owns can make the truck arrive any sooner.
Who owns the switch
This is the oldest lesson on the Conway lakes, and it has only ever changed costume. The English built a whole life on something they did not control, the orange crop, and a cold snap they could not plan for carried it off in two nights. More than a century later, the neighborhood that grew up on the same water still runs on something it does not control, the power on the wires, and the storms still switch it off.
The fruit was never really the point, and neither is the grid. The point is the question Florida keeps asking the same patch of ground: when the thing you depend on fails all at once, do you own anything that keeps your own lights on. The colonists answered no, and went home. A homeowner on the lakes today can answer differently.