In 1888 a woman in Eustis, Florida sat down and wrote a letter to Washington, D.C., because her orange trees were sick and no one around her could say why. It was not the sort of letter that usually changed anything. This one did. Four years later the United States government sent two young men south to her town with orders to figure out what was wrong, not just with her trees but with the orange itself, and they set up in a grove on the edge of a lake and built the first citrus research laboratory in the world.
A town that was really one crop
Eustis had started as a steamer stop. Before the railroad arrived in 1880, it was a small port on a chain of lakes, Harris and Eustis and Dora and Griffin, where boats carried people and goods through the Florida interior. Then the track came, the town incorporated in 1883, and the thing it decided to be was a grower of oranges.
It was good at it. The sandy ridges and the lakes that held off the worst of the cold made this one of the best citrus districts in the state, and Eustis leaned all the way in. For a while it called itself the Orange Capital of the World, and the claim did not feel like bragging. The hotels, the bank, the stores on Bay Street, the fair exhibits stacked with fruit, all of it rested on the grove.
That is a fine thing to be, right up until the one crop has a problem. And by the late 1880s the groves around Eustis had several. Trees were dying in ways nobody understood, from diseases that had no names yet because no one had ever sat down and studied them.
Two young men and a letter
The letter that reached Washington in 1888 came from a Eustis resident, Mrs. Tom Platt, asking for help with sick citrus. The Department of Agriculture, newly interested in what was happening to the nation's crops, decided to answer it with people.
In 1892 it sent two of them. Walter T. Swingle was about twenty. Herbert J. Webber was in his mid-twenties. A local grower named Frank Savage gave them seven acres to work, and on that ground the two built what is generally called the first citrus research facility in the world, the Subtropical Laboratory at Eustis.
Their first job was simply to look, carefully, at an orange tree and write down what they saw. Nobody had really done it. Working out of the Eustis grove, Swingle and Webber became the first to describe and name the diseases that had been quietly ruining the crop, blight and foot rot and dieback, melanose, psorosis, scab. Putting a name on a thing is the start of being able to fight it.
The promise in that work was enormous, and you can feel why the town welcomed it. If the orange could be understood, studied, bred, defended, then the one thing Eustis had staked everything on could be made safe. The grove would stop being a gamble.
They came to make one crop unbreakable. Two cold nights would show that the crop was never the fragile part. The town was, because it had nothing else to stand on.
The winter nothing in the lab could stop
The threat, when it came, was not a disease. It was the weather. In the winter of 1894 to 1895 two freezes crossed Florida, the first in December, the second that February, and together they did something no fungus ever had. They killed the groves outright.
A hard enough freeze does not prune a citrus tree. It takes the fruit, then the leaves, then the wood, and in the worst of it the tree itself down to the roots. Across the region the crop the lab had been sent to protect was simply gone, and with it the money in every grower's pocket. The Orange Capital of the World had almost nothing left to be capital of.
The lake-cooled district that had felt safe turned out to be as exposed as anywhere. All the disease science in the world could not add a single degree to a winter night.
Breeding for the thing they couldn't control
Here is where the Eustis work turns, and where it stops being a sad story. The scientists did the only thing that actually answers a freeze. They tried to build a tougher tree.
They began crossing the sweet orange with the trifoliate orange, a scrubby, sour, cold-hardy relative that could take frost the eating oranges never could. The hybrids they made were called citranges, among the earliest deliberate attempts to breed cold resistance straight into the crop, and they grew out of the wreckage of that freeze. In 1897, at Eustis, Swingle also crossed a tangerine with a grapefruit and produced the fruit he named the tangelo.
A tangelo, first bred at Eustis
None of it came fast enough to save the groves that had already died. In 1897 Swingle and Webber were called back to Washington, and the little lab in the grove wound down. The great experiment in making the orange safe had been overtaken, in a single season, by a problem the experiment was not built for.
The grove that became the whole world's
What the two men started at Eustis did not stay at Eustis. It became the foundation of modern citrus. Webber went on to Cornell and then to California, where he ran the University of California's Citrus Experiment Station at Riverside for decades and helped write The Citrus Industry, the reference the whole business still leans on. Swingle spent his life on citrus too, naming and sorting the family and hunting new plants around the world.
The hardy hybrids and the breeding methods that were figured out partly in a Lake County grove ended up in orchards on several continents. The sick trees of one Florida town turned into the science of a global crop.
Eustis itself did the slower work of not being only an orange town anymore. The groves came back, and later freezes knocked them down again, hardest in 1983 and 1984, until most of the trees were finally gone for good. By then the town had other things holding it up, which was exactly what it had lacked in 1895.
The Citrus Museum, on Lake Eustis
On the museum grounds down on the lake there is a historical marker, put up in 1954, and near it a tangelo tree. The marker credits Webber, Swingle and the Savages for the citrus breeding that started in Eustis. It is a quiet thing standing next to the water, and it is most of what is left on the ground of the lab that tried to outthink a freeze.
What the letter really asked
The woman who wrote to Washington in 1888 asked how to fix her oranges. The answer she set in motion fixed the orange for the whole world, which is more than she could have hoped for. But it could not fix the thing underneath her question.
That thing was never the disease, and in the end it was not even the freeze. It was that a town with only one thing to lose loses all of it at once, on a night it does not get to choose. No laboratory in a grove could change that. The only answer to it was the one Eustis took a century to find, which was to not be a single crop in the first place.