In the early 1880s a German printer in Buffalo, New York, sat down and wrote the sales pitch for a town that did not yet exist. He could afford to build it. A few years earlier he had patented a small iron device that locked rows of type tight inside a printing press, and the patent had made him comfortable. Now he was selling something harder to manufacture than a printer’s tool. He was selling weather.
The booklet he mailed north was titled On the Back Bone of Florida: Gotha, New Colony, Orange County, Florida. The “back bone” was the sandy ridge that runs down the spine of the peninsula, and his promise was simple. Come to the high ground, where the winters are mild and the air is healthy, buy a few acres, and grow oranges among your own countrymen.
His name was Henry Hempel, and he was about to find out what you actually get when you sell a climate by mail.
The man who sold a climate
Hempel had come down to Central Florida himself around 1879, bought up close to a thousand acres of pine and scrub, and by 1883 had a town drawn on paper. He named it Gotha, after the old cathedral city in Thuringia he had come from. On April 20, 1885, the colony was formally founded.
He did not just draw it. He built the bones. A sawmill that cut the local pine into boards for Winter Park and Maitland and crates for the orange growers. A general store. A post office, running since 1883. A school. A hall. Gotha was one of only two German colonies ever planted in Florida, and Hempel meant it to be a particular kind: a freethinkers’ colony, settled by people who put reason ahead of the old pieties they had left behind.
A German town in the pines
The pamphlet worked. German families read it in the cold northern cities and came south: the Koehnes, the Mohrs, the Friedrichs. Charles Koehne ended up postmaster and kept the store. By the 1890s Gotha was genuinely lively in a way that had nothing to do with oranges.
The men built a Turnverein, a German gymnastics-and-social club, and in 1887 put up a Turner Hall for gymnastics and dances and minstrel shows, and at some point a bowling alley. Thirty-odd Germans, out in the Florida pine woods, rebuilding the Saturday nights of home.
Underneath the music, the money was citrus. The groves paid for the halls and the stores and the lots, the same as everywhere else in the lake country. And a colony that ran on oranges was a colony that ran on the one thing Hempel had promised but could not actually control.
The man who believed the pamphlet
One arrival took the promise about the climate more seriously than anyone. Dr. Henry Nehrling, a naturalist and horticulturist, started buying Gotha land in the mid-1880s and eventually moved his family down and built Palm Cottage Gardens, an experimental garden where he tried to grow plants no one believed could survive this far north.
Nehrling’s whole life was an argument about exactly that. The grove owners around him were making the same bet in oranges that he was making in caladiums and palms: that the ground Hempel had chosen was high enough, and the winters kind enough, to let tender things live. For about a decade, the bet looked won.
Two nights in the winter of 1895
Then, over two winters, the climate they had bought stopped cooperating. A freeze swept Central Florida in December 1894. The trees were just pushing new growth when a second, harder freeze hit in February 1895. Together they are still remembered as the Great Freeze, the worst in the state’s recorded history.
It killed the orange trees to the roots. The money the colony ran on was gone in a season, and the ridge Hempel had chosen for its high, safe ground turned out not to be high enough to matter. Families who had crossed an ocean and half a continent on the promise of mild winters packed up and left to find work. At the Lutheran congregation, when the counting was done, only nine families remained.
What a colony becomes when it stops booming
Nehrling kept at it, hauling his most tender experiments farther south over the years as the cold kept reminding him where he was. The families who stayed in Gotha mostly stopped trying to get rich and settled for living there. The place that had been drawn as a colony quietly became a neighborhood.
Even the Germanness got harder to keep. When the First World War came, “Lutheran” and “German” blurred together into something a Florida town was nervous to be, and Gotha’s Zion congregation dropped its German-language services and closed its German school. The pamphlet had sold the place on being a German colony. Within forty years that was the part it was quietly putting away.
Here is what makes Gotha unusual: it never came back, and eventually it decided not to. Windermere incorporated next door. Ocoee and Winter Garden grew into cities. Orlando sprawled out to meet them, and Disney opened a few miles south in 1971. Gotha did none of it. It never incorporated, so it has no mayor, no town hall, no town utilities. In 1995 Orange County formally named it a “rural settlement,” and the people of Gotha have spent the decades since using that designation to hold off annexation and keep the lots an acre wide and the oaks standing. The colony that failed to boom turned staying small into the whole point.
What’s still there
You can still read the original town in what is left of it. Hempel Avenue is still the main street, still carrying his name. The little Gothic church at the corner of Gotha Road and Hempel Avenue, built in 1913, is still standing, and the Zion Lutheran congregation has kept it since 1921.
Still the corner it started on
The old country store, a building that goes back to the colony days, still stands on Hempel Avenue. These days it is a restaurant called Yellow Dog Eats, and people line up at it under the trees. The 1916 schoolhouse is the community center now. Nehrling’s Palm Cottage Gardens is on the National Register and still open, his stubborn tropical plants still in the ground.
The old store, still feeding the town
Nehrling’s garden, still growing
A colony sold on a safe climate, saved in the end only by staying too small to matter.
The one thing the pamphlet couldn’t promise
Which brings the whole thing back to Hempel’s card, and the one thing he could not put on it. He could promise high ground and mild winters, and he could even deliver the ground. What he could not sell, what nobody can, is a guarantee that the sky will hold up its end.
The Great Freeze made that point in 1895. The oaks make a quieter version of it now. On August 13, 2004, Hurricane Charley came ashore in southwest Florida as a Category 4 and drove inland through the Orlando area, a track almost no one expected a hurricane to take. Across Orange County it knocked out power to tens of thousands of homes, and in a place like Gotha, where the century-old canopy sits directly on the county’s lines, that is how the lights go: an oak limb, in the dark, across a wire no town is coming to bury.
Gotha chose, on purpose and over a hundred years, to stay a place where the weather still gets the last word. No wider roads, no buried lines, no town utility, just the acre lots and the oaks and the quiet it fought to keep. It is a beautiful choice. It has just never been a safe one.