There is a photograph of a four-story hotel with cupolas and wraparound verandas, the kind of building you would expect to find in a capital city, and it is standing in the Florida pine on the shore of a lake most of the country had never heard of. A New Orleans newspaperman named Alexander St. Clair-Abrams put it there on purpose. He had decided that this spot, Tavares, would become the great railroad center of the state and, if he could manage it, the capital of Florida itself, and he was spending his own fortune to prove it.
A city ordered into being
St. Clair-Abrams founded Tavares in 1880 and named it for a Portuguese ancestor. He was not looking for a quiet town. He wanted a metropolis, and he was willing to build one out of nothing. By his own reckoning he put at least half a million dollars of his own money into the ground here: a sawmill, stores, a cigar factory, lumber mills, and the hotels and rail lines that were meant to make the place matter.
What he believed in, past everything else, was the railroad. In the 1880s a railroad decided whether a town lived or died. It was the power of the age, the force that moved people and citrus and lumber and mail, and a place with enough track running through it could pull the rest of Florida toward itself. St. Clair-Abrams meant for all of it to run through Tavares.
Five railroads aimed at one lake
So he aimed railroads at it. He chartered and organized lines out of Tavares reaching in every direction: toward Orlando and the Atlantic, toward the Gulf, toward the steamboat port up at Sanford. By the late 1880s the clearing that had been empty pine a few years earlier held something like thirty stores and businesses, a four-story opera house, two luxury hotels, and five railroads converging on it.
The grandest of the hotels was the Peninsular, and it drew the kind of guest who was supposed to prove the whole experiment was working. The Duke of Sutherland and other British noblemen came and stayed. When the Tavares, Orlando and Atlantic Railroad opened, the town made a celebration of it, and a local woman named Ella Tucker posed for the camera in a costume built around a model train.
A steam engine standing at the Tavares depot was not a novelty in those years. It was the point of the place. The trains were why the hotels filled and why the groves had somewhere to send their fruit, and for a short stretch the bet looked like the smartest one in Florida.
You do not run five railroads into a lakeside clearing unless you are certain it is about to become the center of everything. In Tavares in the late 1880s, almost nobody doubted it.
He aimed five railroads at a patch of pine and called it the future capital of Florida. It took one spark off one of those same trains to show how much he had staked on a single thing.
An afternoon in 1888
The thing he had built everything around is the thing that took it down. In 1888 a spark from one of the railroad’s own locomotives caught in the dry wooden heart of downtown, and the fire ran through the business district in a matter of minutes. The Peninsular Hotel burned. So did much of the town around it, block after block of the place St. Clair-Abrams had spent a fortune raising.
Then came the quieter blow, the one with no flames in it. With the center of his model city in ashes, the Florida legislature crossed Tavares off the list of places it would consider for the state capital. The largest version of the dream did not end with a vote St. Clair-Abrams lost. It ended because, after the fire, nobody would take it seriously.
Then the cold finished what the fire started
The town rebuilt, the way towns do. And then the weather did to Tavares what it did to much of Florida in those years. Back-to-back freezes in the winters of 1894 and 1895 killed the citrus the railroads existed to carry. With less fruit there was less to ship, less reason for the trains, less money in anyone’s pocket. Investors left. Residents left. St. Clair-Abrams himself, bankrupt, gave up on his capital and moved to Jacksonville to practice law again. The place he had willed into being came close to simply emptying out.
Everything that had made Tavares special was tied to the one system, and the one system was faltering. There was no second engine underneath it to take the weight.
What a county seat is good for
One thing saved the town, and it was a piece of paper. In 1887, before the fire and before the freezes, Tavares had been made the seat of the new Lake County. A county seat has a reason to exist that does not depend on hotels or British dukes or five railroads: the county has to keep its records and run its courts somewhere, and that somewhere was Tavares. The town shrank hard, but it did not vanish, because the county still needed it to be there.
The courthouse that outlasted the dream
The columned courthouse that anchors downtown today was finished in 1923, and it still stands on the rise above the water. It outlasted the ambition that laid out the town around it.
The city on the water, again
What Tavares did next took most of a century. It stopped trying to be the capital of anything and leaned into the one thing it actually had, which was the water. It sits on Lake Dora, with the old cypress-lined Dora Canal nearby, and in the modern era it rebuilt its downtown along the lakefront and opened a city-owned seaplane base out on the water. Today Tavares calls itself America’s Seaplane City, and on a good weekend the planes come down onto Lake Dora in front of a crowd.
A seaplane down on Lake Dora
It is a smaller claim than capital of Florida. It is also one the town has managed to keep.
The problem with running everything through one thing
St. Clair-Abrams bet a town on a single system. He ran everything through the railroad, built the whole place to lean on it, and for a few years it looked like the shrewdest move in the state. Then one spark off one of those trains showed the flaw in running everything through one thing: when it fails, it does not fail halfway. The hotel with the cupolas, the one standing improbably in the pine, was gone in an afternoon, and the capital went with it.
The town that survived did it by finding something the trains could never carry away, which was the lake it had been sitting beside the whole time.